Creamy Caramels

Creamy Vanilla Caramels

Making candy during the holidays has certainly required a bit of patience and perseverance. However, my love for caramels has kept me trying, but the most important thing I have learned over the years of failed attempts…. there is no room in your kitchen for a cheap thermometer! Before you even buy the ingredients, buy a quality thermometer, preferably digital so you can accurately measure the temperature of your candy. Another important tip to consider, which honestly I only learned very recently, but, altitude matters. We live in Big Sky Country at about 5,000 feet. That is very different from when I made caramels in Montgomery, Alabama, at 240′. That would explain why my recipe has a pencil adjustment of about 8-10° since we returned to Montana. If you don’t make adjustments, you will likely overcook your candy at higher altitudes. A good rule of thumb is to reduce the cooking temperature by 2 degrees every 1,000 feet above sea level – unless of course it was written originally by someone living at the same altitude. For instance, my original recipe said ‘cook and stir until a thermometer reads 244,°’ and when we returned back to Montana, the first few batches were rock hard and boy, was I disappointed! Especially since they were perfect down south! Now, I have adjusted my recipe to 238° and we’re back to being just about perfect.

Creamy Caramels

Prep Time10 mins
Cook Time45 mins
Course: Dessert
Keyword: candy, caramels
Servings: 80 peices


  • 1 cup butter
  • 2 cups sugar
  • 1 cup light corn syrup
  • 1 can (14 oz) sweetened condensed milk
  • 2 tsp vanilla extract


  • Line an 11 x 7 in. dish with foil; spray the foil with non-stick cooking spray or grease with 1 tsp. butter.
  • In a large, heavy saucepan, combine the sugar, corn syrup and 1 cup butter. Bring to a boil over medium heat, stirring constantly. Reduce heat slightly to medium-low; boil gently without stirring for 4 minutes.
  • Remove from heat; gradually stir in milk. Cook and stir until a candy thermometer reads 236-244°, depending on where you live. (You want a higher temperature if you are at sea level, a lower temperature if you live at high altitudes. At 5,000', I boil to 238°.) Remove from the heat; stir in extracts. Immediately pour into the prepared pan. Let stand until firm, at least an hour or two.
  • Using the foil, lift out the candy upside down onto a cutting board. Remove the foil. Using a sharp knife, cut the caramel into 1×3/4 in. pieces. Wrap candies individually in waxed or cellophane paper; twist ends.


You can get creative with your flavors! 
I  recently replaced 1 tsp of vanilla extract with maple extract.  However, orange, apple cider, coffee, buttered rum, or any other flavor you like could be used as well.
I  used to cut wax paper into squares until I  found an Etsy shop, Sweet CO1 in Minnesota where I  could purchase 1,000 candy wrappers for less than $12. Not only are my candies prettier, it was way less hassle and all my wrappers are uniform in size.
*Recipe adapted from, 2013
Maple Vanilla Caramels

I hope you enjoy this wonderful tradition as much as my family has.


Copyright © 2020 Montana Mountain Maven / Tina R. Cusker. All rights reserved.

Autumn Apple Harvest

For over two weeks I have been slicing and peeling apples by the dozens thanks to some very generous colleagues with a bounty to share. I’ve already made 5 pies, 3 dozen apple cinnamon muffins, apple cake, apple onion & yellow squash gratin, AND two dozen caramel apple cinnamon rolls. What’s next on the menu?

You’ll be the first to know when I finally decide… and hopefully I’ll get them finished before the pears and plums show up.

Read More

Easter Sunday Dinner… memories and treats to share

When you are 14 years old and incredibly self-conscious, even a 6am Easter Sunday Sunrise Service warrants a finished hair-do and makeup. It was practically the only day of the week I could sleep until 7am, so I wasn’t exactly thrilled at the idea. I grew up attending Sunday School and church every single Sunday, in a family church dating back to our family’s German immigrants, so it wasn’t like I was protesting attending church on one of the busiest Sundays of the year – it was all about the hour! And watching the sunrise at the same time was not exactly what I would consider necessary, or even all that special. The sun rises every day! Interestingly, this year, we actually considered attending a sunrise service, which made me chuckle just a bit thinking back to those least favorite Easter memories.

For me, Easter is about family. It is a day to celebrate the resurrection of Christ. It is a season of rebirth, spring, sunshine and white shoes. I was raised on the family farm and every Easter Sunday started with an extra special gift my father would bring home from my Grandmother. After feeding the cattle, he would stop into my grandparents home to say ‘good morning’ and chat for a few minutes, and on this particular day, she would carefully cover and hand over the basket painstakingly decorated and filled with chocolate marshmallow rabbits and eggs, solid chocolate eggs, and pastel colored m&m’s. My sister and I could hardly wait for the basket to arrive on this one day each year, diving into it as soon as it landed on the kitchen counter. When my children were growing up, I took great pleasure in filling their baskets with chocolate treats, a new outfit, a toy, video or in later years, gift cards for their favorite stores.

Read More